Search This Blog

Saturday, October 17, 2026

The Swerve: PRR's Solution to a 4-Track Problem

When one thinks of a 4-track railroad, what comes to mind for most people is a 4-line highway with two adjacent "carriageways" each consisting of a inner track for non-stop trains and an outer track for stopping trains (2+2). However there is another arrangement, commonly seen in the UK and some other parts of Europe, where the 4-track line consists of parallel 2-track lines with stopping trains on one pair and non-stop on the other (1+1+1+1). 

The most famous example of this in North America was the New York Central's Water Level Route in upstate New York.  A two track "passenger" line running in the typical "left hand" fashion ran too the south of another two track "freight" line running in the opposite "right hand" fashion. (The stated reason for this was to have trains on the center tracks running in the same direction to reduce the severity of freight vs passenger derailments.) To enable this system a giant flyover was constructed in the town of Fullers to switch freight trains from left handed to right handed operation. 

New York Central's Fullers Flyover

One state to the south, the Pennsylvania Railroad took a different approach. While it had never been afraid of constructing flyovers, the NY Central's route featured freight yards all on the north side of the tracks so keeping passenger trains out of the way made a lot of operational sense. For the PRR, center tracks for express/freight and outer tracks for local/passenger worked fine, but yards could present a capacity bottleneck as slow crossover movements tied up the main line. While flyovers, slow speed terminals or yards situated entirely between the main tracks were common, another PRR tactic was to switch between 2+2 and 1+1+1+1 configuration about one macro block away from the yard. This allowed freight trains to cross over at track speed as opposed to a yard crawl. 

 

Added extra turnout, not PRR material.

The typical way to do this sort of split most often involves extra crossovers to enable parallel movements. Examples of this arrangements can be seen at the old BRILL interlocking south of Philly and the less old Bellrose section of QUEENS interlocking. Both these examples also made use of higher speed turnouts, Limited in the case of old BRILL and 80mph for QUEENS. The PRR chose a different path that eschewed a universal type crossover in favor of a limited crossover with one of the center tracks making a swerve from one side of the center to the other. This ostensibly provided three full speed routes with the rest making use of higher speed turnouts (#20). The two best examples are R and CP towers on either side of Pitcairn Yard near Pittsburgh.


Before I dig in note that in the 2+2 zone tracks labeled freight could also be used by passenger trains and also engineers had a degree of speed flexibility to navigate the routes according to the turnout angle. Anyway, at R interlocking above both westbound tracks get straight shots with freight traffic benefiting from the "swerve" as they accelerated out of the yard. Eastbound freight that was already slowing for the yard would get a limited speed diverging route down track #1. Only eastbound non-stopping (ie passenger) traffic would have to slow and take a medium speed route from track 1 to track 3, but this would still limit latency (and route conflicts) compared with a heavy freight. Meanwhile non-stopping westbound trains on track 4 would have their choice of  track 3 via a limited speed crossover. 


We see a similar arrangement east of Pitcairn Yard. Here eastbound passenger trains benefit from the swerve going from track #3 to track #2 over a Clear signal with a limited speed route to track #1. Eastbound and Westbound freight enjoy parallel crossover routes while westbound non-stopping trains get a Clear route on track #4 and a limited speed route on track #3. Again 3 of the 4 tracks can enjoy parallel clear routes through the mixing bowl with only eastbound non-stop having the potential to cause conflicts when going to track #1. 
 

Another, slightly watered down version of the swerve was VIEW interlocking in Duncannon, PA where traffic switched from the 1+1+1+1 fashion heading in and out of Enola Yard and the Rockville Bridge, to the 2+2 fashion of the Main Line proper. Eastbound passenger trains get the straight shot on track 2, while eastbound freight trains get the swerve from track 2 to 3 over a single limited speed turnout. Westbound freight has the option of a straight shot onto passenger track #4, but can also take a single limited speed turnout onto track 3 while westbound passenger is stuck with the double diverging move from track 2 to track 4. The 19 crossover allows westbound freight traffic to make parallel moves with eastbound freight traffic, but its also unclear what regular movements the #7 crossover allows apart from a fun alternate path for westbound freights. 
 
The old high speed equilateral turnouts at Bellrose.

Because of all the diagrammatic oddities at R, CP and VIEW I suspect the PRR was using turnout geometry to generally bump speeds above what defines Medium and Limited speeds today. A system of high speed equilateral turnouts was most notably employed in the old old Bellrose section of QUEENS interlocking to provide for diverging speeds of 60-80mph and could likely be leveraged to minimize diverging latency on what was officially a 70mph passenger / 50mph freight main line since back in the day engineers has much more flexibility when it came to speed regulation. Let me know if the comments if you think the PRR was trying to be clever and boost speeds or trying to be cheap and save on switch hardware.



Saturday, October 10, 2026

K TOWER Closes Ending Tower Ops on the NEC

The ax finally fell for Washington DC's K TOWER, 4 years after the interlocking station was relocated from the 1908 tower structure and into an office in the old Railroad Express Agency building. As of October 2026, control of the Washington Union Terminal complex has passed from the operators at K to the new "Section K" desk at CTEC in Wilmington. The move is similar to the one that closed R and Q towers in Sunnyside Yard in October 2025 and replaced them with a new Section S dispatcher at Penn Station Control Center. 


While not expected the move is not surprising seeing as rising labor costs have swamped the advantage of having eyes on the ground, especially after Amtrak trialed having the K Tower staff shut up in an office playing video games without a good view of the tracks. K TOWER effectively functioned as a mini-PSCC with at least 3 staff positions, two Train Directors (ostensibly split between Amtrak and MARC moves), and an Assistant Train Director. (There might have also been a 4th position to handle paperwork.) The new Section K desk at CTEC initially tried to do away with the Assistant TD position, but was later forced to add it back given the workload. It is unclear if TD's were upgraded to dispatchers or remained at the lower grade. 

 
Like other recent tower closures, the impetus wasn't so much the number of "butts in seats", but the overhead involved with managing a satellite control facility. The staff at old K would need its own extra board and some form of supervision. The DC area has higher cost of living than Wilmington and travel between Wilmington and DC for management or training probably involved at least some claims for personal vehicle milage. Unlike train crews, dispatchers and operators are limited by Federal hours of service rules to 9 hours per 24. That means one can't easily extend existing shifts to cover an outage. Someone has to come in on a rest day or you have to have an qualified extra. With the pool of regular workers around 12-15, there likely aren't enough off days to keep an extra man fully utilized, however they themselves need the flexibility to take off. By moving everyone to the CTEC dispatch centre, the K Tower operation can be covered from the existing, fully utilized, extra pool, which saves not only a salary, but also management spoons in case someone calls in sick.

 
As I pointed out in the title, K tower closing marks the end of tower operations along the entire Washington to Boston Northeast corridor. This process started in the early 1980's when the Northeast Corridor Improvement Project began to replace the PRR's legacy interlocking towers moving south to north with CTEC first being stood up in the attic of 30th St station. The 1990's saw tower closures between Philly and Metropark with the "last mile" into NYC staying tower controlled (and paper dispatched) until UNION and DOCK tower were closed in 2009 and 2017 respectivly. On the Boston end the yk2 era electrification project closed all remaining main line towers on the Shore Line and Metro-North closed SS75 (NEW HAVEN) around 2003. Even the off-main line towers like SOUTH BAY (Southampton St yard) and R/Q (Sunnyside Yard) have been rolled up. While ZOO is still open, it no longer controls any NEC traffic and LIRR's HAROLD may no longer serve as an auxiliary control location after the local interlocking was rebuilt for East Side Access. While this marks a sad day for distributed control, the NEC's three independent dispatch centers (Wilmington, PSCC and Boston) can hopefully provide some protection against mass outages.