Search This Blog

Sunday, January 14, 2024

Velcorp Gems - A New Signal Supplier Enters the Fray

While out riding the new MBTA Green Line Extension I noticed a new corporate brand stenciled onto the back of a cheap looking transit type LED signal head.

My original assessment that  Velcorp is the company and GEMS is the brand name of their rail signaling equipment turned out to be incorrect as Velcorp was actually Virginia Electronic & Lighting LLC and GEMS was their subsidiary General Electronics Mechanical Services, which I guess does all the rail stuff? Anyway, as you can see below the product looks to be on the low end of the build quality scale with exposed nuts on the front, lots of hard angles and what appears to be a non-locking access door on the rear.

 


The mounting equipment is branded as Harmon, which may be doing business under the Landsay brand now. Each signal also has a pair of mounting brackets on the top that look a bit like owl tufts. From Velcorp's website it looked like they had previously focused on LED modules before suddenly getting the contract for the GLX wayside signals. Velcorp isn't local so maybe its a Veteran owned small business or something.


Despite their appearance, the signals seemed to work well enough. Still, I have not encountered them on any other transit system. Velcorp is one of several entrants into the rail signal space to have offered up products competing against the legacy brands of US&S and GRS (Alstom) who have the capability to make larger cast aluminum and iron housings.


Saturday, January 6, 2024

1994 SUISUN BRIDGE Cabin Tour

 Movable bridge cabins are the invisible step children of the interlocking tower scene, but its easy to forget that they have all the same stuff that regular towers have including the full compliment of electro+mechanical interlocking machines. While poking around YouTube I found this video of someone's 1994 tour of the Souther Pacific's SUISUN BRIDGE movable bridge cabin. This vertical lift drawbridge is a crossing of the Carquinez Strait, which connects Suisun Bay with San Fransisco Bay and hosts Amtrak's Capitol Corridor, Coast Starlight and California Zephyr services.

As far as I am aware it is still a staffed interlocking station, although I am not sure if it retains the US&S Model 14 machine and panel seen throughout the video (specifically 10:30). In the video you can also hear the sound of a signature US&S pneumatic switch machine at 4:00 as it locks down the lift span under the control of a Model 14 lever.

Based on intro and outro clips of ABS searchlight signals on the south bank, I suspect this pre-dated the era of SP style tri-light signals that remain at the bridge today and therefore implies that the Mode 14 was replaced by a panel or VDU.

Westbound home signals SUISUN BRIDGE

The panel shown at various points in the video also lacks the VISTA crossover immediately west of the eastbound signals.

Westbound home signals VISTA interlocking with eastbound home signals SUISUN BAY

So it looks like the "Southern Pacific" style re-signaling was going on quite a bit later than I had figured what with the mid-90's Union Pacific merger.

Sunday, December 31, 2023

2023 Searchlight News

 For the last post of 2023 I'm going to go through my backlog of searchlight related news items. First up is the Florida East Coast where we are all aware of the re-signaling in the Brightline Zone, but it appears that the remaining searchlights on the north end are also on the way out. The Bayard siding, just south of Jacksonville, had no evidence of signal replacement in Feb 2023, but new masts were in place by September.

Up on the former B&M Main Line east of the CSX zone in Ayer, there was been a good deal of searchlight attrition, but this has been a piecemeal process and at milepost 425 near the VT/NY state line the MP 435 searchlight was still standing as of may 2023.

East of Ayer CSX hasn't quite had enough time to start re-signaling projects as they are still trying to rebuild the connector from Warcester to Ayer. Getting out to the two searchlit interlockings between the Lowell and Fitchburg MBTA zones are high on my list.

Up on the former Montana Rail Link the searchlight replacement is ongoing with new signals up around EAST BOZEMAN.

Unfortunately around 2019-2022 many remaining searchlights on the BNSF San Bernardino Sub lost its ATSF vintage searchlights except for a few around the Riverside Station.

Finally on the UP/BNSF Joint Line south of Denver, an interesting situation has developed where CTC has been added to one of the two former single direction ABS tracks and the other has been left as ABS with no PTC due to a lack of need. This has at least temporarily saved a number of searchlights, including the mast at Milepost 226.8 just of US 85 north of Castle Rock, which has had a replacement hovering over it since 2018.

That's all for now. Remember there's no time like the present to get out and get your photos. I'll be doing a followup piece on re-signaling on the New England Central line in the CT River Valley in a few months.

Friday, December 22, 2023

The Last N&W CPL Dwarfs?

It's sometimes easy to forget that the PRR position light dwarf signal was also used by PRR ally Norfolk and Western Railway in addition to the regularly sized position lights. Their PL dwarf was even included in the 1959 N&W program to partly colorize their signals resulting in something that gave off definite UK "ground signal" vibes, albeit with the ability to display green.


Although the old N&W has been ravaged by re-signaling projects over the last decade, there are still a number of well preserved lines deep in the Appalachian coal country and Virginia. However the same cannot be said for the N&W CPL dwarf as the N&W had color light dwarf alternatives in its rulebook as early as 1961. Therefore the N&W had a multi-decade head start on replacing its PL dwarfs at the point where NS started to get involved. As of the time of this post, it has been reported that there are only 4 N&W PL dwarf signals remaining in active service at three locations. The first location is Iaeger, WV, the second Coeburn, VA and the third, with two CPL dwarfs, is Cloverdale, VA.


The Iaeger example is immediately adjacent to state route 80 just east of the Tug Fork bridge at IAEGER interlocking, just past the west end of Auville yard on the Pocahontas Division Dry Fork Branch near the village of Hull where the three track N&W position lit full crossover used to be.

The Cloverdale pair are located at the east end of the Cloverdale Branch on the Roanoke District's CLOVERDALE interlocking about 8 miles north of the Roanoke Terminal in Roanoke, VA. The first governs the end of a long industrial track that serves a concrete plant and the second serves as the exit signal for the Cloverdale siding. 

The final location is actually an automatic distant signal on the otherwise unsignaled Toms Creek Branch for COEBURN interlocking on the Pocahontas Division Clint Valley District. It is located just off Tate Ave, a few blocks from the VA state route 158 and the central business district. All three locations are in the vicinity of recent re-signaling efforts and can be considered highly endangered as a couple of other known examples, including another isolated automatic distant in North Carolina, were recently lost.

Of course rare signal types have always popped up before and I'm just reporting on the results of a forum discussion so if you are aware of an N&W CPL dwarf that has been missed please let me know in the comments! The first draft of this post actually missed the Coeburn dwarf so thank you Oakley for pointing it out.


Sunday, December 17, 2023

BNSF CTC Replacing Union Pacific Julesburg Sub ABS/TWC

Just a heads up that about 24 miles of ABS/TWS (aka Rule 271) on the Union Pacific Julesburg Sub in northern Colorado is being converted to CTC as BNSF takes over maintenance of the entire Bush Sub/Julesburg Sub corridor between Union and Sterling, CO. This line represents one of those dual operating arrangements where as traffic levels dropped, two competing railroads turned their parallel lines into a single joint. In the case of the Bush and Julesburg Subs, the division point was the small railroad location of UNION.

Over the last decade or so BNSF upgraded their side of the line and, as their traffic levels increase, they gained more control and have decided to apply CTC to the Union Pacific portion of bi-directional ABS. Although Union Pacific ABS signaling had eliminated use of the pole line and installed PTC, it also made use of short mile long signal blocks with US&S N type color lights at mileposts 77, 70, 69, 67, 66 and 65 in addition to fairly uncommon late model US&S modular color lights at mileposts 71, 72, For example the CTC interlocking replacing the ABS hand throw siding end at MP 58.8 in Sterling will have its distant at the MP 61 signal location. Union Pacific appears to have already been reducing the block length with 2 mile jump to a new Safetran signal at MP 63. The project will also include new interlockings and the currently hand throw searchlit ABS siding between WE and EE MESSEX and two new intermediate signals at mileposts 79 and 78 between MESSEX and UNION. 

 

It remains to be seen if BNSF will remove/replace all of the old UP intermediates or just those directly adjacent to one of the new interlockings, but for anyone in the area all of the existing signals are easily accessible from public highways including US 6 and County Rd 178.

Saturday, December 9, 2023

Results of FRA PTC Braking Algorithm Study

I recently discovered the results of the FRA's Positive Train Control Passenger Braking Algorithm Enhancement project dated September 2023. As regular readers are aware I have been a frequent critic of the overly conservative braking algorithms used by various PTC systems and vastly under perform the performance capabilities of the rail vehicles. While this FRA study was confined to the entirely wireless ETMS system used outside the northeast, it might still offer meaningful improvements to these systems in general. Long story short don't get your hopes up. In fact the results of this study might make things even worse.

So I encourage everyone to try and work their way through the linked paper (mirror here), but in my quest to add value I will provide a summary of the key points. The study examined four potential algorithm enhancements, Target Approach Management (TAM), specified consist length trains, tuned train types, and adaptive braking. TAM is for low speed (5-10mph) approach to stop signals while the other three are general purpose braking algorithms that better take into consideration various quirks of passenger train and EMU/DMU operation. The study was almost entirely carried out via computer simulation where real world variables like train consist, rail adhesion and brake pipe latency were tested in tens of thousands of combinations to estimate real world performance. There also appeared to be real world tests carried out on a test track.

The first important takeaway is that the performance baseline for defining an "undershoot", as in PTC stops the train too quickly is 500 feet for speeds under 30mph and 1200 feet for speed over 30mph. Under the baseline scenario these limits were exceeded 20-25% of the time. The PTC braking algorithms calculate a stop point probability distribution and then add a safety factor. Higher speeds mean more uncertainty so the typical stop point for 25mph might be a couple hundred feet short of the signal, the stop point for 90mph could be multiple thousands of feet short. This is why PTC forces so much aggressive braking at line speed.

As for the results of the study the good news was that the new TAM algorithm improved low speed undershoots (defined as more than 100 feet) from nearly 50% under the current proprietary EMTS implementation to a fraction of a %. Unfortunately that's all the good news you are going to get as the other "improved" general purpose algorithms blew up undershoots in the simulated runs. Specified Consist undershoots increased between 9 and 17% with some passenger train consists undershooting up to 40% of the time. Tuned Train Type saw mixed results with some equipment having less undershoots and some more. Adaptive showed no change for the commuter type equipment while undershoots for passenger type equipment went up from 20 to 30%. The gain for this drop in performance was an improvement in meeting the stop target from 98 to 99%. The real life tests resulted in a mixed bag of performance gains and losses, however unlike the costless simulations far fewer real life tests could be carried out and under much more limited conditions.

The problem with the study is that it ultimately treats a safety overlay system like autonomous operation. PTC isn't what has to stop a train before it hits something. That's the job of a skilled locomotive engineer. PTC is what should step in when the Engineer is clearly going to be doing something unsafe. Even unsafe conditions rarely lead to physical impacts at which point the crash safety system prevent potential injury or death. PTC preventable accidents of all types were already rare and PTC should eliminate at least 98% of those. Meanwhile poor train performance is pushing riders onto the roads where they'll die in car accidents. Celebrating a 1% improvement in PTC effectiveness at the cost of yet more performance isn't the win the FRA thinks it is. The infuriating part is that over on those highways self-professed self driving cars are blowing throw stop signs left and right and Federal regulators do nothing.

Saturday, December 2, 2023

Caught on Camera: CSX's Gonzo Distant Signals

Distant signals, as defined as those that appear in otherwise unsignaled territory to warn train movements of an upcoming absolute signal (ie an interlocking), are seen in two flavors in the North American scene, fixed and dynamic. Many year's ago I discussed the use of dynamic distant signals on some Conrail Shared Assets lines in Southern New Jersey and although fixed distant signals are far more common, dynamic distants aren't remarkably rare. Today, most signaling systems make use of two possible distant signal rules. Approach the next signal prepared to stop and approach the next signal expecting a proceed indication of a type defined by route knowledge. As these appear in unsignaled territory neither of these conveys track occupancy information between itself and the absolute signal. CSX on the other hand defined its distant signals by a marker plate that, like the vomiting emoji, can be applied to any signal.

In practice the CSX App Marker would only be applied to Clear, Approach, Approach Limited, Approach Medium, Approach Slow and Restricted Proceed/Restricting. Basically anything that would normally appear on an automatic signal before an interlocking. Now of course this wouldn't be a "Caught on Camera" post if I didn't find an exceptional example of this system. In Cartersville, GA the unsignaled Cartersville Sub approaches the W&A sub at a wye interlocking designed BOWEN. At some point after 2012 CSX re-signaled the W&A sub and installed a new App marked distant signal right off Sugar Valley Road, seen below.


Unlike the typical dynamic distant with two lamps, yellow and green, this example has 5 lamps including a fixed yellow in the uppermost head. This was because the west apex of the wye was interlocked and could give a slow speed route and a medium speed route. Therefore the Sugar Valley Road distant can display Y/R/R Approach for a stop or restricting, Y/G/R Approach Medium for the medium speed route and Y/R/G Approach Slow for the slow speed route. Of course because it doesn't reflect track occupancy the most restrictive indication is Y/R/R Approach as seen here next to an approaching train movement. Ironically, the approach lit distant signal is indirectly reflecting the occupied nature of the block by being lit so at some level, the App Marker lies 😅.