LINCOLN Lefty: Story of the PRR's Left Handed Dwarfs

 Anyone looking at the NORAC signal aspect charts may have noticed that the familiar PRR dwarf position lights have a curve to them (or yaw) that can go both ways. For all four dwarf indications, Slow Clear, Slow Approach, Restricting and Stop, one will see two entries on the diagram chart, one with a left hand curve and one with a right hand curve. To the uninitiated this can be dismissed as having to do with clearances or which side of the track a dwarf signal is placed, but it actually represents a fairly early change by the PRR to make a more practical signal vs a more conceptually accurate signal. 

The first PRR position light signals were designed as a replacement for semaphores. Version 1 or "tombstone" position lights (due to the shape of the backing) consisted of 4-lamp lines with an off-center pivot point that directly mirrored the shape and function of a semaphore blade. The position light dwarf signal was no different, but used two lamps to mimic the right to left sweep of a dwarf semaphore. Originally only three positions were provided, stop, low speed prepared to stop and low speed, again matching the function of the dwarf semaphore. 

Between 1918 and 1925 the three lamp system with circular mounting became standard for high signals, but the dwarfs, unable to be simplified further, retained the design aesthetic of a semaphore blade sweeping out a curve. The one major change was that someone noticed that the 4-lamp PL dwarf could display the reverse \ for free and a distinction between "proceed expecting stop" and "proceed expecting obstruction" was able to be made. The result was the left-handed dwarf position light.

Made of cast iron by Union Switch and Signal, the left hand dwarf had bulb access hatches on both the straight and curved sides. The rest was a sealed unit with a small vent on the back. 
 

This model of PL dwarf would go on to be installed at all the great PRR signaling achievements of the 1930's such as ZOO and HARRIS, however the march of progress is never satisfied and the desire to simplify the design merged with the desire to reduce confusion. The new dwarf would be reversed such that the curve would proceed in a high hand direction with the Restricting \ position being reduced in size compared to the Slow Approach / Position. The design was also changed to one with a single large rear access door, possibly enabled through advances in large gasket technology. 

The new style position light proceeded to almost entirely replace the old, especially as the staffed interlocking towers and their electro-mechanical interlocking machines were replaced by CTC starting in the 1970's. By the 21st century left handed PL dwarfs were a rare sight with most appearing at those parts of Amtrak and Conrail territory that had escaped re-signaling since the 1930's. However while out at LINCOLN interlocking on Amtrak's Northeast Corridor in Metuchen, NJ, I spotted a left handed survivor  governing movements out of the MoW yard.

Somehow escaping replacement in the early 90's when LINCOLN tower was closed and re-signaled, LINCIOLN's 5W dwarf is now one of the more accessible left-handed PL dwarfs, mounted on the side girder of the Lake St bridge for all to see.

Hopefully it will escape scrutiny and continue to perform its job for years to come. 

Amtrak's New Position Light Configuration

Following from Pennsylvania railroad practices, Amtrak used the following two configurations for all of its "complete" position color light mast signals at interlockings. They either have a lunar white Restricting \, or they don't. In both cases the single central lunar white Stop and Proceed marker has been retained.  

While most other North American railroads have shifted to using Restricted Proceed in place of Stop and Proceed, Amtrak, and the NORAC rulebook for whom Amtrak is the biggest member, have both retained the Stop and Proceed practice.  

So consider my surprise when saw the recently installed colorized position light signals at Amtrak's new LEGGETT interlocking on the Hellgate Line. The restricting \ is present, but, please correct me if I am wrong, I believe this is the first time I have seen Amtrak PL interlocking signals without a Stop and Proceed marker. 
 

Part of  the Penn Station Access Project, these colorized position lights are the first of many that will wipe out the last stretch of amber position lights on the NEC (PHIL is a point, not a stretch) and they appear to indicate a shift at Amtrak towards that all important stop before entering an occupied block.

In case your wondering the typical Amtrak signal progression is to display a Stop and Proceed if there is an obstruction within the interlocking limits and a Restricting (if available) if the interlocking is clear, but the block beyond is not. The stop certainly seems like a worthwhile safety precaution, but the distinction between it and Restricted proceed is minimal, mostly just the salience of entering a stretch of track with an obstruction or broken rail. 
 

As you can see the new signals on the replacement Portal Bridge have retained the Stop and Proceed marker, but that project was designed and specified some years before Penn Station Access. So it remains to be seen if this is the shape of things to come, or a one off trial. 

 

 

No Approach! The Duality of Uncommon Signals

We all learn about traffic lights in elementary school.  Red means stop, green means go and yellow means slow or caution. These are the basics of automatic block signaling that also tend to get taught in entry level railroading books. Now its pretty logical that a signal might lack the ability to display a clear indication. A permanent stop condition or the end of automatic block territory are both situations where a Clear signal would not ever apply. However there are a few situations where signals in North America can display Stop or Clear, but not Approach on the full speed head. 

The first is at interlockings outside of automatic block territory like a diamond crossing or drawbridge. The signal provides movement authority through the interlocking and without track circuits outside of the interlocking limits there is no "prepare to stop" points an Approach type signal would apply to. Trains will have their own movement authority like a track warrant so a clear signal is basically the interlocking telling the train "you do you". One might expect signals in this case to display a Restricting indication, instead of a clear, and sometimes they do, but that is going to come with a 20mph speed restriction, or less, which can be a time hit on unsignaled lines with higher track speeds. 

The next situation, Manual Block territory, would be very familiar to those in other parts of the world. Although almost extinct in the US, there remains a bit of manual block still in service on the LIRR and the way to identify a manual block signal is the lack of an approach indication. (This also applies in general to historic PRR signaling charts.) Signals will display Stop or Clear Block with any Approach functionality handled by a separate distant signal towards the end of the manual block. The PRR even went one further sometimes substituting the \ "Caution" indication in place of / Approach. 

Sometimes its really not good to have locomotives stopped and waiting at a specific signal,  Maybe there's an issue with a grade crossing, or noise, or diesel exhaust. In this case it would not be desirable for trains to approach that signal prepared to stop, so a preceding signal will either hold trains short or allow them to approach a signal with some sort of proceed indication. The most notable of these is at the entrance to Washington Union Stations 1st St tunnel that the currently diesel hauled northbound trains cannot enter without having a signal displayed further on that allows them to leave said tunnel. Another nearby signal location at CSX's LENFANT interlocking might lack southbound approach signals for a similar reason due to an overbuild.

One somewhat PRR-specific situation is where interlockings are provided with exit signals and because of the short distance between the interlocking's entrance signal and exit signal, Slow Approach is used instead of Approach. This creates an upper head that can only display --- Stop or | Clear. The C&O also made frequent use of exit signals, but seemed to keep their upper head Approach indication, although Medium Clear to exit Approach allowed the C&O to minimize the use of R/Y/Y/ Medium Clear.

A fairly new situation where Approach has been "omitted" involves high speed turnouts. At certain points on the NEC, Amtrak has decided to combine a flashing green "Cab Speed" signal indication with R/*Y* Medium Approach. At the end of a main track that converges into another via a high speed turnout, the result will be an upper head with green and red lamps/positions and no yellow lamp/position.
 

New Signals Up At THORN

 Although not much has changed regarding the ultimate fate of THORN tower, recent photos do show what the new signaling situation is going to look like. In the eastbound direction the triple signal bridge covering tracks 1, 2 and 5 Running, have gotten the Safetrain upgrade with Rule 562 'C' boards turned. Although not yet in photos, it is expected that track 4 will also be getting a PL mast signal to replace the existing reverse direction dwarf. SEPTA is tentatively resuming service to Coatesville upon the completion of new station facilities in 2025 which includes a semi-restoration of #2 track to a point just past the new station for the daily NS regional freight. 

In the westbound direction new PL masts are up on tracks 1 and 2 to replace the reverse direction dwarfs and its assumed that a new gantry mounted signal will be in store for #4 track.  The real surprise is what looked to be a new westbound full PL mast signal on what used to be the Low Grade Freight Line track. The old THORN had maintained a vestigial signal in that same location, but despite the rationalization of the former 6-track full crossover, it seems the low grade stub track has not only been retained, but is being prepared for use. What that use might be remains to be seen, but a mast capable of displaying Medium and Limited speed signals could imply SEPTA trains making some sort of switchback maneuver after discharging on Thorndale's track #4 platform or coming out of some yet to be built storage tracks on the footprint of the old PRR Thorndale facility. 

The THORN interlocking cutover is still planned for later in June with DOWNS to lose its switches before complete removal. GLEN and FRAZER will be turned over to the dispatcher by the end of 2025 closing THORN as an active interlocking station.

Cleveland Line Autos Now on the Way Out

 In another example of either speaking too soon or rolling under the lowering door like Geordi, it has been reported that NS is planning on removing the remaining Cleveland Line ABS Position Lights I recently reported on. 

Scuttlebutt is that NS actually needs the parts to maintain the PL's on the western Fort Wayne Line, however I suspect that after the East Palestine explosion closed the Fort Wayne Line, the lack of PTC on the lower Cleveland may have become an issue. No word on the timeline, but I'll try to track the progress and if the project is a 1 for 1 signal replacement or something that will convert the line from ABS to CTC.

Hidden Gems - Cleveland Line PRR ABS Signals

The whirlwind of PTC motivated re-signaling has wiped out vintage ABS and CTC systems all across the country including most of the main line PRR position lights. However in one tiny corner of Pennsylvania not only exists a remnant population of PRR position lights, but position lights in a single direction ABS configuration. The Cleveland Line between CP-ROCHESTER (Conway Yard) and Alliance, Ohio serves as a backup route for the far more popular Fort Wayne Line. Due to the low traffic volumes is it PTC exempt, which explains how the PRR era signals have hung on. All together there are 6 PL signal locations on the dual track ABS segment between Rochester, PA and Yellow Creek, OH and today I will cover them all in an eastbound direction using photos that were taken over three trips in 2021, 2022 and 2023. 

The first location is at milepost 22 at the east end of Wellsville, OH. It consists of one eastbound PL mast and a new westbound Darth Vader mast that was installed in the late 2010s when CP-YELLOW CREEK was re-signaled. It is located just outside the flood wall and is lit full time with PL signal 221 displaying clear by default and signal 222 Approach.

The next location is at milepost 19 right behind the football stadium of Westgate Middle School in the town of East Liverpool, OH. It consists of two single head PL masts, both continuously lit with a Clear signal indication.

The location is also notable for the presence of 1940's vintage Carnegie steel rail and a somewhat ad hoc run of signal wire between the cabinet and rails.

In the East End section of East Liverpool at the site of the closed Virginia Ave railroad crossing we find the milepost 16 location with another pair of PL masts. This time signal 164 displays Approach by default due to a pair of interlockings, VEZ and MIDLAND, at either end of a single track section a few miles to the east to the east. Because the track #1 does not encounter a diverging route at VEZ interlocking the corresponding PL mast needed no modification and was therefore not replaced. The short single track section seems to have been installed due to the risk of RoW erosion by the Ohio River, but also acts as a "Conrail Crossover". The eastbound 164 signal is also significantly taller than the opposite 165 mast.

The relay cabinets associated with the signals display both US&S and Wabco logos.

Seeing as VEZ and MIDLAND took out the following two ABS locations, the next automatic signal location is across the PA border, just east of te town of Midland and directly adjacent to state route 68 at milepost 8.6. It consists of an eastbound position light and westbound Darth Vader which are lit full time with Clear the default indication eastbound and Approach the default westbound. They are co-located with the Midland hotbox, dragging equipment and high car detector.

Amtrak FAIR Interlocking Loses Its Quirks

 A little while back I discussed the evolution of NORTH PHILADELPHIA interlocking from its construction in 1914 to its disestablishment in 2005. Early urban interlockings such as NORTH PHILADELPHIA were colorful characters with all sorts of extra infrastructure to handle not only the main line traffic, but also stuff like industrial switching, yard and light engine moves. FAIR tower in Trenton, NJ is not only NORTH PHILADELPHIA's sibling in appearance, but also in its arc through history. While I don't want to get too deep into the history and evolution of FAIR, I will say that it was drastically expanded in the 1930's, then entered a series of successive diets in the late PRR, Penn Central and Amtrak eras before the tower was closed around 1994.

In its second to last iteration that lasted from around 1990 to about 2020, FAIR had lost all of the double slips and freight support it had maintains up through the end of mineral traffic on the Belvidere and Delaware line. It's primary function was that of a passenger terminal for the Philly and New York area commuter services that terminated there. The two remaining quirky features were two additional tracks at the far northern and northerner limits of the right of way. Track 7 was used to store SEPTA equipment, while "North Low Track" served as an extra place to stash New York bound peak period trains overnight. Below you can see how the plant changes from its late PRR configuration to post CTEC configuration.

The area of interest is the North Low and Hill Tracks. The Hill Track used to connect with the Bordentown Secondary to Camden which saw limited passenger service like the famed Nelly Bly NYC to Atlantic City express train. In the commuter era that was used as precious storage space, keeping alive the old configuration that used to serve Doodlebugs that would run into Trenton from rural South Jersey.

 

While eastbound movements out of North Low could be made via the "Wall Track" past the tower, this involved a Restricted speed signal. The preferred option was the 86 switch protected by the 6BE and 8BE signals. This was located at the eastern end of the platform with 4 dwarf signals protecting the single low speed switch. One of the dwarfs was mounted on a striped stick for better visibility.

At the west end of the platform was another left-hand turnout, the 86W switch and associated 6BW and 8BW dwarf signals. You are seeing things right in this only allowed for North Low access from the hill track. This became an issue when around 2005 NJT opened up its Morrisville Yard west of Trenton in Pennsylvania, turning all of the terminal traffic that needed to be shuffled about into run-through traffic. Trains arriving from Morrisville could not access the North Low and as you can see from the rust, it became disused. 

Starting in 2019, Amtrak brought the rationalization hammer down on this legacy configuration. The 86W switch was reversed, the Hill Track was removed and the 16 switch from Main Track 1 was fixed up for higher speeds. Now trains from Morrisville can access the North Low, making it potentially useful again. Unfortunately the next step came with the same interlocking refresh that removed all of FAIR's pneumatic point machines. The 86 switch and its associated signals were completely removed.

Trains using North Low will now have to take the slow route past FAIR tower and them on 0 Track to HAM interlocking, but as you can see from the grass, it is unlikely there will be a need for North Low any time soon. While this all makes sense, especially in the age where efficiency is more and more important, the 86 switch and its dwarf signals are still a loss worth noting.

The Last N&W CPL Dwarfs?

It's sometimes easy to forget that the PRR position light dwarf signal was also used by PRR ally Norfolk and Western Railway in addition to the regularly sized position lights. Their PL dwarf was even included in the 1959 N&W program to partly colorize their signals resulting in something that gave off definite UK "ground signal" vibes, albeit with the ability to display green.

Although the old N&W has been ravaged by re-signaling projects over the last decade, there are still a number of well preserved lines deep in the Appalachian coal country and Virginia. However the same cannot be said for the N&W CPL dwarf as the N&W had color light dwarf alternatives in its rulebook as early as 1961. Therefore the N&W had a multi-decade head start on replacing its PL dwarfs at the point where NS started to get involved. As of the time of this post, it has been reported that there are only 4 N&W PL dwarf signals remaining in active service at three locations. The first location is Iaeger, WV, the second Coeburn, VA and the third, with two CPL dwarfs, is Cloverdale, VA.

The Iaeger example is immediately adjacent to state route 80 just east of the Tug Fork bridge at IAEGER interlocking, just past the west end of Auville yard on the Pocahontas Division Dry Fork Branch near the village of Hull where the three track N&W position lit full crossover used to be.

The Cloverdale pair are located at the east end of the Cloverdale Branch on the Roanoke District's CLOVERDALE interlocking about 8 miles north of the Roanoke Terminal in Roanoke, VA. The first governs the end of a long industrial track that serves a concrete plant and the second serves as the exit signal for the Cloverdale siding. 

The final location is actually an automatic distant signal on the otherwise unsignaled Toms Creek Branch for COEBURN interlocking on the Pocahontas Division Clint Valley District. It is located just off Tate Ave, a few blocks from the VA state route 158 and the central business district. All three locations are in the vicinity of recent re-signaling efforts and can be considered highly endangered as a couple of other known examples, including another isolated automatic distant in North Carolina, were recently lost.

Of course rare signal types have always popped up before and I'm just reporting on the results of a forum discussion so if you are aware of an N&W CPL dwarf that has been missed please let me know in the comments! The first draft of this post actually missed the Coeburn dwarf so thank you Oakley for pointing it out.